Mojo - The Music Magazine

Features Disc of the day

Fiona Apple
Extraordinary Machine



Apple’s much-anticipated third album. When the online hoo-hah died down it turned out it was brilliant.

Fiona Apple

If Fiona Apple’s reputation as a Maya Angelou-quoting, self-help-bible-bashing Women In Rock cover star saw her unfairly ghettoised (and it certainly had - what male songwriter of similar breadth and appeal would be dismissed as a “kook”? Hello, Anthony?!) Then the rumours surrounding the delay of her third album didn’t help. Suppressed by her record label? At loggerheads with her producer? The subject of an online pressure group and apparently on the verge of packing it in to explore the therapeutic benefits of farm animals. Whatever. See wikipedia for the full poop. When it was finally released in Extraordinary Machine was, happily, strong enough to disassociate her from the Lilith Fair stereotype forever. It’s not that her obvious eccentricities and willingness to draw on personal trauma are absent, but they are tempered. Extraordinary Machine is an evolutionary step on from the piano-pounding grit of her debut, Tidal, and the baroque artfulness of The Pawn (here’s the full 90-word title). The elaborate arrangements on the opening title track offer a clue to the original sessions, with pizzicato strings, marimba and dramatic flourishes propelling it to centre stage. It’s a masterpiece, but a whole album might leave you uncomfortably full. Instead we get roomier piano-driven arrangements and familiar failed relationships on Window (“Better that I broke the window than him / Or her / Or me.”) or Not About Love (“I miss that stupid ape”), plus an insistent chorus and Beach Boys-ready theremin on the knowing Please Please Please (“Please, please, please / No more melodies / They lack impact, they're petty / They've been made up already”). It’s moody, oddly funny, self-aware and crucially, transcends the hype.

Jenny Bulley

Posted by Danny_Eccleston at 6:00 AM GMT 17/11/2008

Further Listening

Antony & The JohnsonsI Am A Bird Now (Rough Trade)

Regina Spektor - Soviet Kitsch (WEA)

PJ HarveyTo Bring You My Love (Island)


Related MOJO content:

Fiona Apple

Comments

Comment on this post


Click here for House Rules

Comment on this post

end of body content back to top

end of footer back to top

Back to top