Mojo - The Music Magazine

Features Disc of the day

The Stones Roses
Second Coming



Their bass player thinks it should have been called Premature Ejaculation. He's wrong.

The Stones Roses

No wait, hear me out. Whilst it could never match The Stone Roses' debut for seismic impact, Second Coming is anything but the malformed freak of legend. A mammoth, Zeppelin-aping folly produced to death by a cocaine-addled John Squire, while Ian Brown was too stoned to intervene? OK, there's some truth in that. But at least half this record is very, very good indeed.

Over eleven and a half minutes, opener Breaking In To Heaven travels up a Mekong River of swampy atmospherics and tribal drumming to find a band at the peak of their musicianly powers. It's heavy rock played with a serpentine dexterity and whispered menace, of a piece with Driving South and Love Spreads - swaggering, ice-cool injections of monkey-gland into the venerable blues-rock format.

Elsewhere, Ten Storey Love Song revisits past melodic glories while the stuttering dance-rock of Begging You remains suggestive of the proto-Big Beat then cooking chez Chemical Brothers. And although some of these goods are half-baked - Daybreak is essentially a six-minute groove looking unsuccessfully for a song - they shouldn't overshadow the sweetmeats elsewhere in evidence. Brown's delightfully laid-back Straight To The Man has a bozo-on-the-Bayou playfulness he captured neither before or since and the stripped-down folk of Tightrope is genuinely touching.

That it only took World War II six more months to complete is inexcusable, but, really, whatever the band produced after their eponymous masterpiece had the fortune to define its era was bound to be found wanting. Of course, it all went tits up from here: drummer Reni left, followed by guitarist Squire, and the less said about 1996's Reading headline slot the better.

"Second Coming," bassist Mani told MOJO in 2001: "it should have been called Premature Ejaculation." He's wrong - it was hardly premature, after all. But judged on its quality and not its gestation period, it deserves a better rep. Had we but known the fiascos that the Britpop era still had in store...

Chris Catchpole

Posted by Danny_Eccleston at 6:00 AM GMT 02/06/2009

Further Listening

Ian BrownUnfinished Monkey Business (Polydor, 1998)

The SeahorsesDo It Yourself (Geffen, 1997)

Primal ScreamVanishing Point (Creation, 1997)


Related MOJO content:

The Stone Roses

Comments

Comment on this post


Click here for House Rules

Comment on this post

end of body content back to top

end of footer back to top

Back to top