Sufjan Stevens – Carrie & Lowell Reviewed: Grief-stricken masterpiece still flaws

Singer-songwriter’s most personal album, now expanded with demos and bonus tracks.


by James McNair |
Updated on

Sufjan Stevens

Carrie & Lowell: 10th Anniversary Edition

★★★★★

ASTHMATIC KITTY

Following 2010’s The Age Of Adz, Sufjan Stevens’s hectic, electronica-infused nod to outsider artist Royal Robertson, Carrie & Lowell returned to sparer, much more intimate songs. Part sparked by his absentee mother Carrie’s succumbing to stomach cancer in 2012 – and also paying tribute to stepfather Lowell, who mailed a 10-year-old Stevens Nick Drake cassettes – it still stands as an unfailingly beautiful and poetic meditation on loss, childhood and adult faith in crisis.

Listening to the bonus disc demo of Death With Dignity, we realise the LP version’s fingerpicked guitar adds a higher-register instance to its ornate lattice, while the demo for Fourth Of July, Stevens’ loving, but unflinching portrait of his mother on her deathbed, stretches to 14 dream-like minutes of between-worlds farewell. Stevens worried Carrie & Lowell was indulgent, but it remains vital, universal, profoundly human.

Carrie & Lowell: 10th Anniversary Edition is out May 30 on Asthmatic Kitty.

ORDER: Amazon | Rough Trade

Track listing:

Death With Dignity
Should Have Known Better
All Of Me Wants All Of You
Drawn To The Blood
4th Of July
The Only Thing
Carrie & Lowell
Eugene
John My Beloved
No Shade In The Shadow Of The Cross
Blue Bucket Of Gold
Death With Dignity (Demo)
Should Have Known Better (Demo)
Eugene (Demo)
The Only Thing (Demo)
Mystery Of Love (Demo)
Wallowa Lake Monster (Version 2)
4th Of July (Version 4)

Get the latest issue of MOJO for the definitive verdict on all the month’s essential new releases, reissues, music books and films. More info and to order a copy HERE!

Just so you know, we may receive a commission or other compensation from the links on this website - read why you should trust us